Thursday, October 30, 2008

John the Careless

It's one thing to see liberals criticize John McCain, what is most interesting is to see conservatives bash him. Of course, you might call these "elitist conservatives," but George Will isn't a "liberal elitist." There is much that I disagree with George Will on, but today's WaPo column about John McCain is on target.

Entitled "Call him John the Careless" -- an obvious paraphrase of "Joe the Plumber" -- Will takes on McCain's decision making and handle on the issues of the day. Nothing is more clear to Will than the carelessness of choosing Sarah Palin as his running mate. As an example of the problem with the choice, Will points to Palin's claim that the VP is "in charge of the Senate." Will says this is either an example of simplification or an unconstitutional grab at power ala Dick Cheney.

She may have been tailoring her narrative to her audience of third-graders, who do not know that vice presidents have no constitutional function in the Senate other than to cast tie-breaking votes. But does she know that when Lyndon Johnson, transformed by the 1960 election from Senate majority leader into vice president, ventured to the Capitol to attend the Democratic senators' weekly policy luncheon, the new majority leader, Montana's Mike Mansfield, supported by his caucus, barred him because his presence would be a derogation of the Senate's autonomy?

Perhaps Palin's confusion about the office for which she is auditioning comes from listening to its current occupant. Dick Cheney, the foremost practitioner of this administration's constitutional carelessness in aggrandizing executive power, regularly attends the Senate Republicans' Tuesday luncheons. He has said jocularly that he is "a product" of the Senate, which pays his salary, and that he has no "official duties" in the executive branch. His situational constitutionalism has, however, led him to assert, when claiming exemption from a particular executive order, that he is a member of the legislative branch and, when seeking to shield certain of his deliberations from legislative inquiry, to say that he is a member of the executive branch.

If McCain is careless as a candidate, would he not also be careless as President? I think that's the point!

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thank you. It is truly sad to see someone "past their prime" trying to journey on with the same aplomb of previous days. It is simply too much for me to fathom that Mr. McCain would hand off the V.P. nomination to someone of whom he had so little knowledge. And,I hope that his continued defense of his choice is simply strategic. If, after seeing and hearing her "in action", he really does not see that he made an enormous mistake, then I fear that he has, in fact, lost the ability to comprehend reality. I hope that we are spared this "ticket" and that his life is yet fulfilling.

Anonymous said...

P.S. ... Let me add to the most previous post that I, too, am "past my prime", so, understand that I am not being critical of anyones AGE. My comment is regarding their capability.