Confessing and Believing (Trevor Hart) -- Review
CONFESSING AND BELIEVING: The Apostle’s Creed as Script for the Christian Life. By Trevor Hart. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2022. Xvi + 336 pages.
Creeds
serve as summations of the Christian faith. As such they represent the way at
least some Christians have believed in a particular moment in time. All told many
different creeds have emerged over time and continue to emerge as Christians
take stock of their faith in a particular moment. Some of these faith
statements carry authority in particular communities. They can be used as
gatekeepers. If you affirm the confession, you’re in. If not, you’re out. Among
these many creeds and confessions, two stand out as especially important. The Apostles'
Creed and the Nicene Creed are embraced in some fashion by most Christian
communities and thus are seen as ecumenical rather than denominationally
specific confessions.
Of
these two ecumenical creeds/confessions, the Apostles' Creed is the briefest
and thus used more often in worship than the Nicene Creed. The Apostle’s Creed,
because of its compact nature is often turned to by theologians who wish to
reflect on the basic elements of the Christian faith. Many of these books, like
the Creed itself, are rather brief in scope, which is not true of Trevor Hart’s
Confessing and Believing. At over three hundred pages (including
endnotes) Hart dives deeply into this central confession of the Christian
faith. Although I am part of a non-creedal tradition (Disciples of Christ), I
have contemplated writing my own reflection. Perhaps that’s because I grew up
in the Episcopal Church and regularly recited the Creed as a child. Thus, I
requested a review copy of this commentary on the Creed to see how this
theologian dealt with its various parts.
The author of Confessing and Believing, Trevor Hart, is rector of St. Andrews Scottish Episcopal Church
and canon theologian of St. Ninian’s Cathedral, Perth, Scotland. Before this,
he served as a professor of divinity at the University of St. Andrews. As noted,
Hart’s attempt to write a reflection/commentary on the Apostle's Creed is not
brief in scope. It runs just under 300 pages, with thirty pages of end notes. In
writing this book, Hart not only seeks to offer a theological reflection on
this ecumenical creed but suggests that it serves as a "script for the
Christian Life." It serves as a description of "mere Christianity,"
and thus is something to be memorized and taken to heart, to nurture the faith
of the believer. Unlike the Nicene and other creeds, the Apostles’ Creed, which
was created to respond to deviant ideas or clarify certain beliefs, offers a
convenient overview of what C.S. Lewis called “Mere Christianity.” Thus, this
was seen to reflect a common set of beliefs held by most Christians. In fact, one
of the founders of my faith tradition, Alexander Campbell, rejected creeds but
when it came to the Apostles’ Creed, he could find nothing there that did not
reflect the biblical witness. In Hart’s mind, the Apostles’ Creed serves as “a
digest of what might reasonably be reckoned to be the bare minimum of these—of
the gist, we might say, of the apostolic teaching” (p. 4).
Regarding the origin of this Creed,
Hart acknowledges that it did not originate with the Apostles. It gets its
moniker, not because of its authorship but because it is assumed that it
reflects apostolic teaching. Its origins are shrouded in mystery, with the
version we have today going back to the ninth century, but there are
predecessor confessions, the oldest being a Greek confession from the
mid-second century used in the church in Rome. As for its contemporary usage,
he notes that in the Anglican tradition, the Apostles’ Creed is generally used
in non-eucharistic services such as Morning or Evening Prayer. For the overall
purposes of this particular commentary on the Creed, Hart suggests that the Creed
is a tool for Christian nurture, something that can be memorized and meditated
on in daily life.
With this introduction to the
purpose of the Creed, Hart focuses the bulk of this lengthy book on diving into
the Creed phrase by phrase, beginning with the declaration “I believe.” Of this
word “believe,” Hart notes that it is a transitive verb that requires an
object. The declaration of “I believe” points us to a list of items to believe
in. He points out that he has chosen to divide/distribute the Creed into twelve
distinct chapters. These chapters serve to unpack the first element of the
confession— “I believe.” He writes that it is not so much what we believe but
who we believe in. That is God as revealed in the person of Jesus, thus the Creed
concentrates on Jesus. In his view, "Christianity is not a set of timeless
'religious' truths about the cosmos but an awkward insistence that the world
itself is a stage on which a divine drama has been played out in history"
(p. 13). The Creed in essence sets out the path on which the Christian embarks.
In this opening chapter, he seeks to define the nature of faith and does so
with some depth. He speaks of faith (the act of believing) as first and
foremost a gift of God. Faith begins with, as we see with Abraham, God’s call
and self-revelation. That “belief” eventuates in a relationship with God. Faith
does involve assent, but it is more than that. It involves knowledge, but it is
also the “conviction of things unseen.” It involves elements that cannot be
scientifically proven. It may be a gift but it also involves a response on our
part.
With this introduction, Hart then
spends the remainder of the book exploring elements of the confession beginning
with the opening declaration of belief in “God the Father Almighty, Creator of
Heaven and Earth.” He continues chapter by chapter exploring each tenet. The first two chapters, “I believe” and the
reflection on the confession of God as Father and Creator, form Part one of the
Book. Part II of the book focuses on the declarations concerning the person of
Jesus. He divides this section into six chapters, beginning with a chapter
reflecting on the confession that Jesus is the Christ and God’s only Son, our
Lord. From there he moves in chapter 4 to Jesus’ conception by the Holy Spirit
and being born of the Virgin Mary. This part of the confession is the tricky
one for many modern Christians, who not only wonder what it means for Jesus to
be conceived by the Holy Spirit, but this statement about being born of the
Virgin Mary can be problematic for many. Hart takes note of the Scriptural
roots of the doctrine of the virginal conception and then deals with the
question of credulity. He acknowledges that to the modern mind, such things as
a virginal conception simply don’t happen. We know how biology works, and this
isn’t possible. Of course, the ancients might not know exactly what we know,
but they knew how things generally worked. While science can tell us what
doesn’t happen, could God who created the universe causing a young Palestinian
woman to become pregnant without a partner? The point he wants to make is that
we need to take confession seriously. As we do this, we, he suggests, need to
let go of the idea that this confession of virginal confession has to do with
the connection of sex and Jesus’ sinlessness—he reminds us that there is
nothing in Scripture that suggests this connection. Secondly, he addresses the
idea that a virginal conception is needed for the incarnation. In his view, it
is s possible to imagine God taking on flesh without being born in this way.
So, taking the confession seriously, why might God do things this way? He
suggests that “in this particular birth as in no other before or since, God is
making a fresh start, initiating a new impulse within humankind, regenerating
our nature by taking it upon himself in order to become, as Paul has it, the
first fruits of a new creation” (p. 98). While his reflection might not
satisfy everyone (I still struggle with this part of the confession), he does
attempt to take the confession seriously and not merely skip over it as just an
example of an earlier time that has no meaning for us. I paused to reflect a
bit on this often-problematic text, but he then moves on to Jesus' suffering,
death, burial, descent to the realm of the dead, resurrection, ascension, and
Jesus' return to judge the living and the dead.
Finally, in Part II he has four
chapters, beginning with the Creed's brief mention of the Holy Spirit, followed
by explorations of the holy catholic Church, the forgiveness of sins, and
concluding with the resurrection and life everlasting. Regarding the Holy Spirit,
with this confession, we turn in the Creed from what God does for us to what
God does in us and with us, and through us. This is where we become involved in
the story.
Comments
Leonard