Consider the possibility -- there might be some things even science can't discern!

Andrew Sullivan, Time Magazine columnist and blogger (Daily Dish) is having that ongoing debate with Sam Harris about the rationality of belief. Now, I'm biased because Mr. Sullivan is representing us theists in this debate. But from my following of the debate, I can't help but feel that Sullivan is getting the upper hand. Though he's not a theologian, he shows considerable theological acumen.

In this debate, Sullivan shows that Harris' intolerance of religion is undermined by his own statements about the possibility that there is more to reality than what science can prove. It may be only a sliver, but there's room for the possibility of faith -- of metaphysics.

If he considers the possibility then there is room for other forms of truth seeking besides science ---

My point here is to say that once you have conceded the possibility of a truth that is not reducible to empirical proof, you have allowed for the validity of religious faith as a form of legitimate truth-seeking in a different mode. The reason why you are not like some other, glibber atheists is that you recognize this. I might say that God has already been in touch with you on the matter.

And so he concludes by returning the serve on the issue of intolerance. Sullivan concedes that Mr. Harris has a point, but Harris refuses to consider the possibility, while even opening the door, perhaps unwittingly --


And that brings me to the asymmetry of our positions. We both accept that there may well be a higher truth beyond empirical inquiry or proof. I respect your opinions in this matter, and feel informed by them. You regard my opinions as inadmissible in public debate, ludicrous, a form of lying, and irrational. Yes, you are being intolerant. More, actually. The entire point of your book is intolerance. Where I respect your position, you refuse to respect mine.

Or maybe, now that I've unpacked it, you respect my position a little more. Let me know,

And so the conversation continues. I hope what I've placed here has whetted your appetite to check out the whole story!

Comments

Popular Posts