The ABCs of Diversity (Carolyn Helsel & Joy Harris-Smith) -- A Review
THE ABCS OF DIVERSITY: Helping Kids (and Ourselves!)
Embrace Our Differences. By Carolyn B. Helsel and Y. Joy Harris Smith. St.
Louis: Chalice Press, 2020. Xiii 189 pages.
Being different isn't a bad thing.
In fact, being different is part of what it means to be human. We come in
different colors, genders, sexual orientations, religions, ethnicities, and
more. While once upon a time there was a "melting pot" theory that
suggested to Americans, who are a diverse lot, that we should all assimilate
into one national identity. Those differences that make us who we are should
melt away. There are still people who hold
on to that idea, and even actively resist diversity education out of the fear
that if we learn how to not only live with but embrace the diverse realities of
our nation then the Eurocentric (White) identity that they believe defines the
United States will be lost. There is, however, a more beneficial path to take,
and it’s one that affirms and celebrates our distinctives. When we can do this
then we can affirm the premise that out of the many we are one people—and that
doesn’t mean becoming a bland melted reality. It looks more like a salad with
lots of ingredients. The question is, how do we help our children understand
the value of these distinctives so that they don’t fear them but welcome them?
Carolyn Helsel and Joy Harris-Smith
have written just the book for the moment. It's titled The ABCs of
Diversity. It's the kind of book that parents, educators, schools, and religious
communities will find valuable as we ponder the impact of our differences in an
increasingly globalized world. Although the book is published by a religious
publisher and authored by seminary professors, tit is a book that transcends
religion. Yes, religion is addressed, but not in a way that will hinder its use
in non-religious settings.
As for the two authors, Carolyn Helsel
teaches preaching at Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary and is an
ordained Presbyterian minister. She is the author of two books that address issues
of racism and White privilege—Preaching about Racism: A Guide for FaithLeaders and Anxious to Talk about It: Helping White ChristiansTalk Faithfully about Racism, both published by Chalice Press (2018) and were
honored by the Academy of Parish Clergy together as their Book of the Year in 2019.
Helsel’s co-author for this project is Joy Harris-Smith, who is a former New
York public school teacher and now serves as a full-time lecturer in speech
communication in ministry at Princeton Theological Seminary, which is where the
two met in a class when both were M.Div. students at Princeton. Helsel is White
and Harris-Smith is Black, thus they bring their distinctive backgrounds to
this important conversation.
The reference to ABCs seems
appropriate when talking about children and education, but it's not just a
witty way of titling a book. They have outlined three sets of ABCs that guide
the conversation about diversity. The first level, speaks of our automatic ABCs
when it comes to differences: Afraid, Back away, and Control. That is how we
often start our engagement with people who are different. While that is where
we often start, that’s not where the authors want us to end up. Thus, there are
two other sets of ABCs to consider. If we can get beyond the first level, then
we can move on to the next level, which is Acknowledge, Be Present, and Come
Closer. This is an expression of intentional engagement, where we acknowledge
our differences, are present to the other, and then draw closer. This is
personal engagement with others. From
there they would have us move to the third level: Access, Build, and Cultivate.
This third level of ABCs is what it will take if we’re to move to a more just society.
That involves cultivating new relationships and experiences, as well as
cultivating within ourselves more capacity for lifelong learning.
The book is composed of eight
chapters. The first chapter outlines the ABCs noted above. Then the discuss how
identities are assigned at birth, especially gender identity (ch. 2). They
remind us that we are complex and complicated entities. They also remind us
that identities are not static. They will change over time. This chapter leads
to a chapter on identity and diversity in action, in which the authors tell
stories of experiencing the growing pains of discovering diversity (ch. 3). From
there we move toward how we experience our differences. There is a chapter on
gender and sexuality (ch. 4), one on race (ch. 5), then religious differences
(ch. 6), and social media (ch. 7). In other words, how is our use of social
media impacting our understandings of identity? Chapter 8 is titled "Old
Enough to Know Better." This is a chapter on microaggressions, and the way
adults relate to each other, which so often influences children. As I write
this review, we're living at a time when a certain segment of the population
believes their right to say and do as they please even if it hurts others all
in the name of freedom. The authors suggest we should know better, though it
appears that we’ve forgotten the lessons learned earlier in life. In fact, it
starts with the concept of common courtesy.
The conclusion of the book is
titled "Choosing Our Place in History." The question is, do we want
to be on the right side of history? That is the question that diversity
education asks of us. Do we wish to live in a polarized world or are we open to
finding ways of building bridges to the future? That is the core message of the
book. It lays down the foundations for helping our children and ourselves make
sense of our differences and positively experience them.
The book then offers three
appendices. The first appendix provides the opportunity for the two authors to
share their experiences of coming to terms with their identities. In these
brief “autobiographies of culture,” we learn about the authors' distinct life stories,
reflecting the differences presented by being White and Black. They write in
the introduction to the autobiographies that “one of the tasks we wanted to
accomplish in this book was to model the kind of cultural excavation we can
each do on our own lives, listening to our own histories and uniqueness, and
sharing that with one another” (p. 124). The second appendix offers
bibliographies, some annotated, of books that can lead to greater empathy,
ranging from picture books to books for older teens and young adults, as well
as a book list for parents. The final appendix provides curriculum activities
for teachers and parents. Here there are two sets of activities. One for
younger children and another for older children and youth.
I believe this is a wonderful
resource for parents and teachers, religious and otherwise. It's filled with
wisdom that emerges from the life experiences of the two authors, both of whom
are parents and educators. The fact that the authors, though both are Christian
and ordained clergy, represent different life stories helps model for us ways
of engaging with one another in constructive ways. If our children are to grow
into adults who embrace diversity, it will be helpful if parents and other
adults can model that kind of life for them. Thus, Helsel and Harris-Smith
offer in The ABCs of Diversity a true gift to parents and teachers that
speaks to our times, especially as forces push back in resistance against
diversity education.
Comments