VULNERABLE GOD: How Jesus Upends Our Assumptions About
God—and Shows Us How to Be Human. By Kenneth Tanner. Foreword by Brian
Zahnd. Grand Rapids, MI: Brazos Press, 2026. Xiv + 224 pages.
It may have started with
Constantine, but I think it goes back further than his decision to embrace
Christianity, since the Christian embrace of an "omnipotent" God, who
can control everything, emerged long before Constantine. Belief in an all-powerful
God can have important implications about how we understand power itself. Is it
possible, however, for Christians to envision God very differently? Might Jesus
reveal that difference as he embodied the divine presence? That is, when Christians try to envision the nature
of the God whom we cannot see, what do we see in Jesus, who is the visible
manifestation of the invisible God? When we ask this question, we need to ask a
further question. Where did he most fully reveal God’s nature? Is it not on the
cross? Although we may turn the cross into jewelry, it was in reality the
cruelest and most humiliating form of execution the Romans could come up with. So,
if Jesus revealed God to humanity while on the cross, do we not see a vision of
the vulnerable God? This may not be the way we often view God, especially if we
wish to use God to justify using power to dominate others. That said, if
Christians do believe that Jesus is the incarnate Son of God, might we not only
gain a different view of God but a different understanding of power?
It might not be the traditional way
of viewing God, but Kenneth Tanner, the pastor of Church of the Holy Redeemer
in Rochester Hills, Michigan, has written a beautiful tome that invites us to
encounter God in the person of Jesus. He titles the book Vulnerable God: How
Jesus Upends Our Assumptions about God—and Shows Us How to Be Human
(Brazos, 2026). That last phrase is important, because in viewing God through
Jesus, whom the Christian tradition understands to be both fully human and
fully divine, we gain a better sense of what it means to be human.
As to the author of Vulnerable God, Kenneth Tanner is a friend and colleague of many years, with whom I
have enjoyed many conversations about the Christian faith. He brings a rather
unique life experience to his ministry and to this book. One of the things I
have appreciated about Kenneth is the way he draws on a wide variety of sources
in his theological reflections. He draws on his experience as a
Pentecostal/Charismatic, Anglican, Evangelical, pastor-theologian
with a strong interest in Eastern Orthodox theology, including the work of Johng Behr, David Bentley Hart, and Sergius Bulgakov. In other words, this is a work
of theology that is rather eclectic, but that will help many come to grips with
the God present in Jesus.
The central theological thread
running through Tanner's Vulnerable God is his affirmation that Jesus is
God, just as the creeds declare. At the same time, also following the creeds,
he affirms Jesus' full humanity. It is in his existence as the God-Man that
Jesus reveals to us God's true nature, while helping us better understand our
identity as humans. In his foreword to the book, Brian Zahnd points out that
Tanner loves icons and is himself an iconographer in the sense that he uses
words that can help us envision God's nature, such that we might be transformed
by our encounter with this icon of Jesus. The icon that he holds most dear is the
Sinai Pantocrator that hangs in Saint Catherine’s Monastery in Egypt.
Tanner writes of this icon that “it is meant to be for us a divine and human
portrait that draws us into mystical communion with the person we behold” (p.
62). It is this mystical communion that Tanner invites us to participate in,
and in doing so, we can “behold the likeness of Jesus in every human” (p. 68).
Tanner divides Vulnerable God
into four sections, each of which emphasizes the ways Jesus helps us understand
God's nature as viewed through Jesus' humanity, even as he invites us to
participate in Christ's divinity such that we might be transformed by that
encounter. Along the way, he walks us through Scripture, even as he draws on a
variety of sources, including his own Pentecostal background as well as his
engagement with Orthodox theologians such as Sergius Bulgakov, David Bentley
Hart, and John Behr. He also draws on early Christian writers including Gregory
of Nyssa, Athanasius, Origen, and others. In fact, I know from my conversations
over the years with him that he finds significant insight from his study of the
early Christians.
The four sections are titled "A Human God," "A Human Life",
"A Human Death," and "A Human Future." As we move from the
mystery that is the incarnation through birth, life, death, and the eschaton,
Tanner writes with an exquisite theological sensibility. Although he is well
read and draws on his own theological training, he doesn't get sidetracked by
debates over critical issues. If you’re looking for a book that wrestles with
biblical criticism, this isn’t that book. Instead, this is a spiritual
reflection on God's identity as reflected in Jesus' human life. In the course
of this reflection, Tanner also brings into the conversation his own life experiences,
especially his pastoral experiences in the church, as a chaplain for first
responders, and simply being present to the community. What we discover here is
a revelation of God that, as the subtitle suggests, upends our understanding of
God.
I offer my thanks to Kenneth
because he writes in a contemplative way. So, even as it is theologically informative,
this book doesn’t become overly caught up in the kinds of details that might distract
us from encountering the God who loves the world and shows that love through
the person of Jesus. As Tanner leads us on this journey through the life of
Jesus and on to the eschaton, he invites us to stop along the way to
contemplate the Gospel's portrayal of Jesus. Because this is a contemplative
vision, Tanner pays special attention to the portrayal of Jesus in the Gospel
of John. He doesn’t give exclusive attention to John, but he finds that portrayal
especially informative. Given this attention to John’s portrayal, Tanner spends
time with the raising of Lazarus and Jesus' encounter with the Samaritan woman,
who, according to tradition, carries the name of Photini. When it comes to the
resurrection, he focuses on Mary Magdalene's encounter with the risen Christ.
Tanner concludes his chapter on Mary’s encounter, writing that “we all follow
Mary Magdalene, who was the first of us humans to announce this gospel” (p. 176).
If you are looking for a resource that will draw you into the person of Jesus, Vulnerable
God does that and more. For as we contemplate Christ, who revealed God's
true identity on the cross, we discover the vulnerable God who loves the world.
This isn’t the God who sits on high, armed with lightning bolts, who justifies slavery
and war. This is the God revealed by Jesus on the cross, the vulnerable God who
shows us how to be human. In writing this book, Kenneth Tanner has written a
beautiful icon of the vulnerable God.
Tanner closes Vulnerable God: How Jesus Upends Our Assumptions About God—and Shows Us How to Be Human with a chapter titled "One." In this
concluding chapter, Tanner focuses on the hymn found in the letter to the
Colossians that describes Christ as the visible manifestation of the invisible
God, who creates all things and holds all things together. He writes of the
Colossian hymn: "The hymn says that everything of God was present in
Christ, who we've learned is human without losing anything divine and divine
without losing anything human. The song says that Christ, as the creator and
sustainer of all things, is the first in creation to live beyond death so that
he can bring everything in creation—all things! —back into union with God"
(p. 211). This reference to "all things" is a key to Tanner's vision
of the vulnerable God who has been revealed to us in the person of Jesus so
that we may all experience union with God. So, in a time when people are
feeling vulnerable, perhaps an encounter with the Vulnerable God whom
Kenneth Tanner describes in this written icon will provide spiritual sustenance
for the journey into the eschaton.
Comments