Friday, September 19, 2014

I Survived a Short Term Mission Trip to Honduras! -- Sightings (Brian Howell)

Many churches schedule short term mission trips for their youth. Some travel overseas and others go to places where need is perceived here in the state. Many go to disaster relief sites. I have been intimately involved in the establishment of a mission station in Detroit. For the past four summers mission teams have been coming to Detroit through two ministries my congregation has partnered with -- Motown Mission and Rippling Hope (Gospel in Action Detroit). Motown just finished its tenth season and is a United Methodist related effort. Rippling Hope has its roots in the Disciples, but it seeks to be ecumenical, while Gospel in Action Detroit is a Michigan Region effort working in partnership with Rippling Hope and Motown Mission.  I share this say that I see the value in Short Term Missions, but I also know that there can be a dark side that needs to be acknowledged.  This mixture is explored in brief in this Sightings piece from Wheaton College Anthropology Professor, Brian Howell.  Take a read and offer your thoughts.  

I Survived a Short Term Mission Trip to Honduras!
Thursday | Sept 18 2014
High School Seniors Mission Trip to Costa Rica (August 2007)                Photo: First Baptist Church Nashville
This past summer, as I waited for my plane in Tegucigalpa, I browsed one of the airport’s many gift shops looking for something for my 14-year-old son and found, among the soccer jerseys and dried toads, a bright orange T-shirt emblazoned with a colorful bus and the black lettering: “I Survived a Short Term Mission Trip to Honduras!”

With most schools back in session, we’re coming to the end of Short Term Mission (STM) season. Waves of missionaries will head out again during Christmas and Spring break. Combining adventure tourism with Christian charity, STMs have exploded in popularity in the past twenty years. Conservative estimates put the number of U.S. participants at 1.6 million per year. These trips of service and evangelism range from domestic stints that may only last a few days to international voyages that last weeks or months. They provide members of every denomination significant encounters with new contexts, unfamiliar cultures, and poverty.

As an anthropologist and a Christian, I have a conflicted relationship with STMs. I find them both fascinating and a bit repulsive. These trips often take relatively naive U.S. Americans into vulnerable communities around the world. While the neo-colonial dynamics are inescapable, the host communities are savvy and the encounter is complex.

I have studied these trips and it is clear that STM groups have served as links to powerful communities (creating “bridging capital”) and provided important resources to under-resourced places. STM travelers attest that the trips are “life changing.” The changes may not always be expected (or desired) changes but there’s no doubt that these encounters cause some visitors to redirect their lives towards service and social justice.

A larger question is “what does the popularity of these trips suggest about U.S. Christianity generally?” Is there something greater to the importance of these travels in the lives of 21st Century Christians?

Scholars of tourism have long argued that tourism is a kind of secular ritual where alienated moderns create liminal spaces in which to experience authenticity andcommunitas. Structuring tourist spaces as “sights,” and tourist performance as “not home,” vacationers uses tourism to escape temporarily the anomie of contemporary life by indulging in hedonism and rituals of renewal.

STMers are well aware of the overlap with tourism, and, in many cases, work very hard to distance themselves from the identity of “tourist.” The most withering critique of these trips is that they’re “just Christian tourism.” Yet STM travelers employ much of the same language of seeking something “authentic,” and of being renewed by their travels that scholars of tourism note as central to tourist narratives.

The difference is that STM travelers seek authentic spiritual experiences, rather than “the real Costa Rica” or “authentic Italy.” The STMer finds “true faith” and people who “really know how to rely on God” among the poor. Contemporary life, cluttered with technology, squeezed by competing demands, and oppressed by pressures to succeed, appears virtually un-Christian when compared with the (seeming) simplicity of the life of the poor. Like retreats, camps, and neo-monastic practices, STMs offer the fragmented Christian self a chance to re-imagine a more authentic and purer faith.

This is not to say that STM visitors exclusively or explicitly romanticize poverty. But even when they hear stories of suffering and exploitation and they express compassion and righteous anger, participants in STM teams often fail to connect the poverty they witness to colonial history, the globalizing economy, and institutional problems.

Too often, the take-away is that we, who enjoy relative wealth, have an obligation to help, but that there isn’t really much we can do. The poor serve as a kind of shrine and the trip as a pilgrimage. The solutions, if there are any, are internal to the country. The only difference we can make, as concerned outsiders, is to sign-up for more trips and to build more houses.

Of course there are models of STM that explicitly address the causes of poverty and the ways rich countries are both implicated and responsible. Christians themselves are some of the toughest faultfinders of STM, and they have in some cases sought to address these cultural dynamics in creative and effective ways. At the same time, there is no doubt that the symbolic nature of the encounter in STM is fraught with overlapping meanings often unexamined by those planning and participating in these trips, some of which work against the intended goals.

As Christians everywhere gear up for the next STM season in December, we would do well to consider how we might make these travels an opportunity to thrive for all who participate on both sides of the trip, and not simply an encounter to survive.

Beek, Kurt Ver. “The Impact of Short-Term Missions: A Case Study of House Construction in Honduras after Hurricane Mitch.” Missiology 34, no. 4 (2006): 477–497.

Howell, Brian M. Short-Term Mission: An Ethnography of Christian Travel Narrative and Experience. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2012.

Linhart, Terry. “Planting Seeds: The Curricular Hope of Short Term Missions Experiences in Youth Ministry.” Christian Education Journal 2, no. 2 (2005): 256–272.

Offutt, Steve. “The Role of Short-Term Mission Teams in the New Centers of Global Christianity.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 50, no. 4 (2011): 796–811.

Priest, Robert. Effective Engagement in Short-Term Missions: Doing It Right!. Pasadena, CA: William Carey Library Press, 2008.

Wuthnow, Robert. Boundless Faith: The Global Outreach of American Churches. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2009.

Wuthnow, Robert, and Steve Offutt. “Transnational Religious Connections.” Sociology of Religion 69, no. 2 (2008): 209–232.

Photo Credit: First Baptist Church Nashville
Author, Brian Howell, (Ph.D. Washington University in St. Louis) is Professor of Anthropology at Wheaton College, Illinois. He is the author of Christianity in the Local Context: Southern Baptists in the Philippines (2008), Short Term Mission: An Ethnography of Christian Travel Narrative and Experience (2012), and co-author of Introducing Cultural Anthropology: A Christian Perspective (2011).

Editor, Myriam Renaud, is a Ph.D. Candidate in Theology at the University of Chicago Divinity School. She was a 2012-13 Junior Fellow in the Marty Center.

Forward to Friend
Sightings Home Page | Submission Guidelines | Reprint Policy
Divinity School
Email us
ALSO from The Martin Marty Center:
Copyright © 2014 UChicago Divinity School, All rights reserved.

No comments: